Podcast: Play in new window | Download
Subscribe: RSS
Gabrielle Amarando: Disappeared in 2012.
Amy McHale: Disappeared in 2016.
Maribel Fresses: Disappeared in 2018.
Nicole Fusaro: Disappeared in 2018. Investigators reportedly recovered video showing Raymond Horsch strangling her.
Blair Tonzelli: Disappeared in 2023.
There are two additional unnamed women whose identities have not been released.
These are the missing women currently at the center of the ongoing investigation centered on Ray and Eugene Horsch’s house on West Chew Ave in Philadelphia. There may be others.
They, and their loved ones, are, and must always be, the center of any story about the investigation.
If you know any information that may relate to the ongoing investigation, please contact Detective Joseph Murray, at the Homicide Division of the Philadelphia Police Department, at 215 686 3334.
You can listen to the first part of this series here, the second part here, the third part here, and the fourth part here.
Please note that all unauthorized reproduction or use of the audio in this podcast is strictly prohibited.
This podcast is 46 minutes long.
—————————————————————————————————
Question: whose lives do we consider important?
We know that when certain people disappear, enormous resources can be mobilized to find them. Police departments hold press conferences. News organizations descend on the story. Photographs appear everywhere. Reporters interview relatives, friends and neighbors. The public becomes invested in finding out what happened.
And that attention is entirely appropriate.
But we also know that it isn’t distributed equally.
When the missing person is a sex worker, or someone struggling with addiction, or homeless, or simply poor and living on the margins, the response can be very different.
There is less coverage. Less public interest. Sometimes fewer resources. And, far too often, an assumption begins to creep in that somehow the circumstances of that woman’s life explain what happened to her.
She took drugs. She sold sex. She went home with the wrong person. She lived on the street. She made bad choices.
As if any of those things make someone less deserving of being looked for. Less deserving of being protected. Less deserving of justice.
The women at the heart of the West Chew Ave case disappeared years ago. Their plight has only come to public attention in recent months.
And perhaps that is one of the uncomfortable things we need to confront.
We are very good at celebrating successful people. Wealthy people. Famous people. People whose lives resemble the lives we imagine for ourselves.
But what if the measure of a healthy society is not how enthusiastically we celebrate those who have succeeded, but how seriously we take the lives of people who are struggling.
The addicted. The homeless. The mentally ill. The poor. The exploited.
The people whose lives are complicated and messy, and who may not always be easy to sympathize with.
If compassion only extends to people whose choices we approve of, is it really compassion?
And this isn’t simply about the police. Or the media. Or the court system. Or some abstract thing we call society.
Society is us.
Which means that this question becomes personal. And in this case, personal to me. Did I pay enough attention?
When I heard things that made me uncomfortable, did I ask enough questions?
When I encountered people whose lives were very different from mine, did I really see them? Or was it easier sometimes to look away?
Those are difficult questions, particularly now.
Because looking back, it is tempting to search every conversation, every encounter, every strange comment or uncomfortable moment for something I should have recognized.
I also know the danger of doing that. Hindsight can manufacture certainty where none existed at the time.
But that does not mean they shouldn’t be examined.
I think we should.
Not because we can somehow rewrite the past. But because we can decide what we do the next time.
We can decide whose disappearance matters. Whose suffering deserves our attention. Whose story is worth telling.
And when someone has fallen through the cracks, perhaps the one of the first questions shouldn’t be what they did to end up there.
Perhaps it should be a personal one: What should I have seen and interpreted differently?
*




I happened on this podcast only this week and am blown away by its integrity and honesty and lack of sensationalism. I have followed the investigation online and it is a mass of click-bait and unpleasantness. This is a tonic. Uncomfortable for sure, but high quality, reflective, and intelligent. Thank you for all you have done to raise the profile of this dreadful crime.
Listening to this now, and as always, impressed with the care and compassion you show for all your subjects – and most importantly in this story, the victims.
I understand this is your last word on the topic. I will miss your considered objectivity.
Thank you. Just thank you.
this story should be mainstream. but capitalism doesn’t care about any people, especially women, who fall through the cracks, so this story isn’t in the mainstream. because the choices these humans have are the ones given to them by those who chose to not to celebrate their lives.
i detest this period of history in which we are living. thank you for making it easier for me to withstand it.
I can see this podcast becoming a multi-part documentary on HBO/Netflix/Prime etc. An excellent job on a disturbing subject. I hope that eventually the fates of these missing women is discovered and any others yet unknown possible victims come to light. I think it’s interesting that when confronting evil we sometimes don’t recognize it until after the fact.
Keep up the excellent reporting!
So he’s killing women even at 75?..If he has access to a crematorium, as was mentioned, they are never going to find some of those remains…I’m sure the son is involved as well…Father and son killers?
In some ways Ray is downright brilliant…Frightening at the same time…
Great reporting as always. Keep up the solid work.
Awesome Article And Podcast Keep Up Good Work
Hey- just wanted to correct something …Gabby actually went missing in 2017. She had been arrested in 2015 and according to her mother, per police the pictures were taken about 9 years ago. I think this is important to note for the timeline of disappearances.
Great work!
I just finished the series. I was really fascinated by how Horsch justified and rationalized his actions and opinions towards women. It does seem that he manipulated everyone to believe his was all an act. Yet, clearly he was a very smart sociopath. I do wonder if his perception of himself as an artist moderated or merely obscured his crimes.
Holy Cow!
This was one of your best series!
You guys always blow me away with your work, that’s a fact.
But, wow!
Ashley, great fan, great podcast. I truly mean great. But two things can be true at once. Yes, the signs were there from the beginning. However, it’s also true that you couldn’t have, shouldn’t have known the extent of this guy’s depravations.
The signs are, that he’s a narcissistic sociopath with a criminal predilection. YET, 90% of the men interviewed here, involved in the 1970s and 1980s coked up, sex industry are narcissistic sociopaths who by their very involvement in a pseudo-legal enterprise speaks towards their criminality. These aren’t judgements, just facts. And that’s not to say that a lot of these guys aren’t caring, honest, stand-up, decent human beings. But the way we act with one another is a minefield of feelings, fears, hurts and reprisals and that’s true for everyone not just adult performers of the golden age. So no, you had no indication that this man, was a serial killer and short of any evidence you’d have had no way to stop him. Don’t let that get to you. 1,000 other people knew him in his life and probably knew him better than you and faired no better at discovering his secret. A serial killer is uncommon amongst the uncommon, there are no real signs because they’re such rare aberrations.
Still though, after hearing five minutes of Ray speak there’s no way I’d have ever left him alone around anyone I loved. When people tell you who they are, listen.